how to shut down an argument

Hey Reader,

You’re in a heated conversation.

Your pulse picks up.

You’re ready to defend your point — to prove you are right.

But here’s the truth:

The moment you focus on yourself, you lose your ability to influence.

So how do you turn that around?

Here are 3 ways to shift any argument from conflict to influence.

#1. Flip the focus.

Most people go into arguments thinking:

“I have to make them see I’m right.”

That mindset triggers defensiveness — yours and theirs.

Instead, ask yourself these questions:

"What do they care about?" or "What are they afraid of losing?"

When you focus on them, the tension starts to drop.

#2. Listen like a mirror.

People don’t calm down when you argue.

They calm down when they feel heard.

Try this:

“It sounds like you’re worried we’ll waste time if we do it this way — is that right?”

You’re not agreeing. You’re reflecting their concern.

This small act lowers resistance and opens the door to real conversation.

#3. Manage the structure, not the storm.

Every argument has two layers: the content (the words) and the structure (the way it unfolds).

As you navigate these two layers, keep your goal in mind:

What outcome do you want?

What do they want?

Where’s the overlap?

You’re not there to win a point — you’re there to steer the direction.

Make this swap in any argument: less proving, more understanding.

You’ll feel calmer and see the situation more clearly.

And that’s when you gain real influence.

You’ve got this.

*Sponsorship Transparency: I only recommend products we use and trust. If I wouldn’t put it in my own home, I won’t put it in yours. Simple as that.

Get daily practice: Join The School of Communication here.

Read all of my past emails here.

No longer want to hear from me? Unsubscribe here.

156 S. Main Street Ste 300 #769, Lumberton, TX 77657

Jefferson Fisher