how to respond to “I was just joking”



Hey Reader,

Ever had someone say something out of line and then brush it off with, “I was just joking”?

It’s an easy way to dodge accountability.

But you don’t have to let it slide.

Here’s 3 ways to respond:

#1: My personal favorite: “Then be funnier.”

If they claim it was a joke, tell them, “Then be funnier.”

You’re making it clear that what they said wasn’t funny. And if they’re aiming for humor, they missed the mark.

#2: “I’m surprised by that.”

This is a complete power move. When you say, “I’m surprised by that,” it forces them into a weaker position.

They’ll likely start asking, “What do you mean?” or “Surprised by what?”

Your response: “I’m surprised you went with that.” Now, you’re the one in control, and they’re left questioning themselves.

#3: “It doesn’t sound like a joke, it sounds like an issue.”

This one really calls them out. After you say, “It doesn’t sound like a joke, it sounds like an issue,” just stay silent. Let them sit with it.

They’ll either admit how they really feel or start backpedaling, realizing they’ve crossed a line.

The next time someone hides behind “just joking,” you’ll know exactly what to say.

J

P.S. Last week, I launched something I’ve been working on for a long time: The Jefferson Fisher School of Communication.

It’s an app-based membership where you’ll get everything you need to handle any conversation with confidence.

Members are already loving the Jefferson AI feature — it’s like having me in your pocket, giving you real-time advice 24/7.

👉 Click here to join now.


Get daily practice: Join The School of Communication here.

Read all of my past emails here.

Inbox overloaded? Set your email frequency here.

No longer want to hear from me? Unsubscribe here.

156 S. Main Street Ste 300 #769, Lumberton, TX 77657

Jefferson Fisher

Simple, practical communication advice for your next conversation.

Read more from Jefferson Fisher

This newsletter is sponsored by Pique. Hey Reader, You can’t control someone else’s emotions. But you can control how much power those emotions have over you. That’s the key to this week’s episode. Because let’s be honest—when the other person gets angry, upset, or defensive, it’s easy to lose your footing. In this episode, I’ll show you exactly how to stay grounded, steady, and in control—even when emotions run high. This newsletter is sponsored by Pique. This week, you’ll learn: How to spot...

Hey Reader, Ever had someone cross the line with you? It’s uncomfortable. Your first instinct is to snap back—or walk away. But neither puts you in control. Here are three simple moves to handle it without losing your cool. #1: Give them 10 seconds of nothing. Don’t say a word. Let the silence do the work. For 10 seconds, they’ll sit alone with their words and replay them. And because you didn’t give the reaction they wanted.... They’ll feel exposed while you look controlled. #2: Name your...

This newsletter is sponsored by Our Place. Hey Reader, You’re in a conversation and suddenly—it’s off the rails. You’re overexplaining. Your voice is rising. You’re filling every silence just to feel in control. But here’s the truth: The more you talk, the more power you give away. In this week's podcast episode, I'm breaking down 3 common mistakes that cause you to lose control in conversations—and exactly how to stop doing them. This newsletter is sponsored by Our Place. Use code JEFFERSON...